« Back to our fieldbook

Barriers and honest tensions

This field is still early, slow and fragile. In our Chapter 7 we wrote that naming a trade-off is more useful than advocating around it. The same applies here.

The barriers sitting in the system

Wire Group and BWL name 5 big barriers we’re facing right now, and all 5 are structural rather than a matter of goodwill.

• Speculative land prices. In much of the Global North, land is priced on what it could yield, not on what it needs. That makes it expensive to shift land to less profitable uses, or to bring it into shared ownership.

• Planning permission. Mundane, and a real obstacle. Many regenerative ideas combine functions (housing, farming, nature, energy) on the same piece of land, which is exactly what most planning rules were built to keep apart.

• Rigid investment mandates. Institutional investors, and plenty of family offices too, work with fixed risk and return requirements. Bioregional finance looks too small, too new, and too unusual to pass them, whatever its actual risk.

• Public goods nobody pays for. Clean water, living soil and social cohesion generate enormous value, and no revenue. The risk of not investing in them is just as badly priced.

• Two languages. The people building the new system and the people holding the capital use different words for the same thing. Changemakers talk about the economy they’re building; investors ask for a track record, collateral and an exit.

Nicole’s work with animal grazing points to another barrier: assets that standard mandates are built to reject. Environmental screens often sort by sector, and livestock scores badly on emissions. But when grazing is well managed, animals can help restore soil structure, water infiltration, and plant diversity. A screen sorts by what an activity is called, not how it’s done —so two herds with very different effects on a watershed look the same to the person reviewing the plan. Given the scale of the livestock sector, this is a real problem for bioregional facilities. They need to be able to assess what a standard mandate is built to exclude, and explain why.

The risks we see

Our own We Diligence work on these projects surfaced a few more barriers worth naming out loud:

• Weaving depends on people. The work is human and deeply local. It relies on the skill of a handful of facilitators. That’s what makes it good, and what makes it hard to copy or scale. Every new bioregion asks for the same years of patience again.

• Governance gets complicated. Local teams, backbone organisations, funders and investors all have a say. In Quípar the team deliberately keeps its governance loose, which keeps things moving now, but could become a bottleneck once bigger money and higher-stakes decisions arrive.

• A lot rests on a few shoulders. In most of these places, a small group of people carries the vision, the network and the trust.

• Incumbents push back. In Murcia, the initiative works right next to expanding intensive agriculture, with real economic and political weight behind it. Regeneration at watershed scale eventually touches those interests.

• Success can price people out. If a bioregion becomes attractive, land and housing get more expensive, and the people it was meant for are the first to be squeezed. Green gentrification is not a theoretical risk. It needs instruments designed against it from the start, such as land held in trust and affordability rules.

• Prototypes can fail publicly. These are first attempts. A visible failure would not only hurt one bioregion. It would feed the story that systemic approaches don’t work in practice.

And then there’s the one from the previous section: if you concentrate a portfolio in one place, a bad decade in that place hits everything at once.

Measuring without flattening

A place like this doesn’t fit neatly into a reporting template, and the projects know it.

In the Quípar Valley, the team monitors together with farmers and residents: soil health, water retention, biodiversity, livelihoods, followed over time. The measuring is part of the intervention. People who observe their own landscape start acting differently in it.

Salmon Returns uses an indicator that needs no explanation: the salmon themselves. When they return in numbers, the watershed is healthy. The team is also developing biocultural credits, which try to put a value on cultural and ecological stewardship. Promising, and also the place where a metric can flatten what it measures.

This is the same balance we looked for in Chapter 4, where Villa Gaia put it as “collaboration is the metric”, and in Chapter 5, where we chose contribution over certainty. In a bioregion, that stance isn’t a compromise but rather the only honest option.